Therapy for Religious Trauma in California
Specialized therapy for adults questioning their faith, recovering from spiritual abuse, or experiencing persistent fear, guilt, and shame associated with harmful religious teachings
online via secure telehealth throughout California
When Your Faith Changes but Fear, Guilt, and Shame Remain
You’ve started reconsidering beliefs that shaped how you understood God, relationships, sexuality, and the future you expected to have.
Some of those beliefs no longer reflect what you think is right or what you want for your life. Others have become questions you’re still trying to answer.
But even as your beliefs change, the expectations you grew up with can continue affecting how you feel about yourself and the decisions you make.
You might still consider yourself Christian but disagree with teachings you once accepted. Or perhaps you’ve left Christianity and are struggling with fears and feelings of guilt that you expected to disappear when you stopped believing.
How Religious Trauma Can Affect Your Life Long After Your Beliefs Change
You want to make choices that reflect your values, but you’re scared of disobeying God.
Perhaps you’ve begun questioning what you were taught about marriage, divorce, sexuality, or the responsibilities of a good Christian.
You know you’re unhappy in your marriage, but considering divorce brings up years of teachings about submission, forgiveness, and honoring your vows.
Or you’re increasingly troubled by how people at your church treat LGBTQIA+ people or other marginalized groups. You grew up hearing that Christians should care for people who are suffering, show compassion, and stand up for what’s right.
But when you express concern about how vulnerable people are being treated, someone you’ve respected for years responds that people need to be held accountable for their behavior and that actions have consequences.
You’re shocked and angry that people who taught you about compassion seem more concerned with judging people who are suffering than helping them.
You’ve started wondering whether you can remain part of a community whose actions increasingly conflict with your values. But speaking up or leaving could jeopardize relationships with people who have been important to you for years.
You’re increasingly aware of what you want and believe, yet you continue feeling guilty when your decisions disappoint people whose approval once meant everything to you.
You’re grieving the loss of certainty and struggling with betrayal by people you trusted.
For years, your faith gave you answers about God, morality, relationships, and how your life was supposed to unfold.
Now you’re questioning beliefs that influenced nearly every decision you made, and some of the questions you’re asking seem impossible to resolve.
You’re also discovering that people you considered close friends aren’t responding to your doubts the way you expected.
Perhaps you told someone you trusted that you were questioning Christianity, only to discover that other people at church know about your private conversations.
Friends who once included you in family gatherings have stopped inviting you. You’ve heard people speculating about why you’re no longer attending church or what must have happened to make you question your beliefs.
You’re hurt that people you trusted with something so personal have turned your uncertainty into a subject of gossip.
Now, as you try to develop friendships outside your religious community, you find yourself holding back.
You’re reluctant to share personal information because you remember what happened the last time you trusted someone with something important. Even when a new friend has given you no reason to doubt them, you worry that they’ll eventually gossip about you, judge you, or withdraw their friendship if you reveal something they disagree with.
You want close relationships again, but trusting people has become much harder since experiencing that betrayal.
You’ve left the church, but the fear of punishment hasn’t gone away.
You no longer accept many of the teachings you grew up with, and you’ve begun making decisions according to your own beliefs.
But you still find yourself worrying that God will punish you for leaving.
You hear a familiar religious phrase or remember something a pastor said about eternal punishment, and suddenly you’re panicking about whether hell could be real after all.
At night, you lie awake reviewing the reasons you stopped believing. You try to reassure yourself that you haven’t condemned yourself to eternal punishment, but the fear keeps returning.
Sometimes you even consider going back to church because you want relief from the anxiety, even though you don’t want to return to the beliefs or environment you left.
You’re frustrated that something you no longer believe can still affect your sleep, concentration, and ability to enjoy your life.
→ You can read more about my treatment approach, including EMDR and somatic therapy, on my main religious trauma therapy page.
What we’ll do together
How I Help You Recover From Religious Trauma
I’m Ingrid Johnston, a licensed marriage and family therapist who has worked with individuals and couples since 2014. I provide religious trauma and faith deconstruction therapy for adults throughout California, combining my understanding of religious culture with specialized training in trauma treatment.
My experience includes EMDR, somatic therapy, and treatment for concerns involving religious shame, persistent fear, relationships, and sexuality.
Reduce the Fear and Anxiety That Continue After Your Beliefs Change
One of the most frustrating experiences after questioning or leaving Christianity is recognizing that a teaching no longer makes sense to you while continuing to have a strong emotional reaction to it.
You understand that disagreeing with your parents doesn’t make you sinful, but their disappointment still leaves you overwhelmed with guilt.
Or you’ve rejected what your church taught you about hell, yet reminders of eternal punishment continue triggering panic or keeping you awake at night.
I use trauma-focused approaches to address the distressing experiences that contributed to these reactions, including memories of religious threats, humiliation, punishment, or experiences in which questioning authority led to serious consequences.
EMDR helps you work through traumatic memories and the beliefs and emotions associated with them. For example, if you spent years hearing graphic descriptions of hell or were publicly shamed for questioning religious teachings, those experiences can continue affecting how you feel about yourself and respond to reminders of religion.
By addressing those experiences directly, we can work toward reducing the fear, shame, and emotional distress they continue producing.
Somatic therapy can also help address the physical anxiety associated with religious experiences, including muscle tension, an increased heart rate, and the urge to escape or comply when someone disapproves of you.
As those experiences become less overwhelming, you can begin living more comfortably according to the beliefs and decisions you’ve made for yourself.
You can disagree with someone without immediately questioning whether you’re wrong, encounter reminders of religious teachings without becoming consumed by fear, and make personal decisions without constantly anticipating punishment.
Develop Greater Confidence in Your Relationships and Personal Decisions
Years of religious expectations can influence how you respond to authority, what you believe you owe other people, and how comfortable you feel advocating for yourself.
If you grew up learning that obedience was a sign of goodness, questioning authority was disrespectful, or putting other people first was always the right choice, those expectations can continue influencing your relationships.
We can address the anxiety and guilt that arise when you disagree with someone, say no to a request, or make a decision that disappoints your family.
We’ll also consider how your religious upbringing influenced your expectations for adulthood.
Perhaps you once assumed you would marry young, have children, remain involved in church, or follow a particular career path because those choices were presented as the foundation of a good life.
Now you’re realizing that your interests, values, or hopes for the future have changed.
Therapy can help you make those decisions with greater confidence, including deciding which religious practices and beliefs you want to retain.
If you and your spouse are struggling because your beliefs are changing while theirs remain the same, I also offer couples therapy for faith deconstruction.
Heal Sexual Shame and Relationship Difficulties Associated With Religious Teachings
Religious teachings about sexuality can continue affecting your relationships and sexual experiences long after you’ve reconsidered those beliefs.
Perhaps you grew up hearing that masturbation was sinful, sexual desire was shameful, or that a good spouse should always be sexually available.
You can love your partner and want to enjoy sexual intimacy, yet still feel embarrassed expressing your desires, guilty about experiencing pleasure, or uncomfortable discussing what you want.
Even after leaving Christianity, you can continue feeling ashamed of sexual thoughts and desires that no longer conflict with your personal beliefs.
I draw on my training in sexual health, couples therapy, and trauma treatment to address these concerns alongside the religious experiences that contributed to them.
We can also examine how teachings about submission, gender roles, obedience, and forgiveness have influenced your expectations of relationships.
As you address those experiences, you can develop greater comfort expressing your preferences, recognizing what you want from intimacy, and making decisions about your relationships according to your own values.
For couples experiencing sexual dissatisfaction, differences in desire, or sexual shame connected to religious upbringing, I also provide specialized sex therapy for couples.
What Can Change Through Religious Trauma Therapy?
Religious trauma therapy can help you move beyond recognizing how your upbringing affected you and begin experiencing meaningful changes in your relationships, decisions, and daily life.
Trust Yourself to Make Decisions About Your Own Life
You can become more confident making decisions about your relationships, career, sexuality, and future, even when people you love disagree with your choices.
You can begin feeling excited about the decisions you’re making for yourself, whether that means pursuing a career you’ve always wanted, developing relationships your former church would have discouraged, or building a lifestyle that looks different from what you grew up believing was right.
Instead of continually trying to fulfill the expectations of your family or religious community, you can decide what kind of life you want and begin creating it.
You’ll be able to consider other people’s opinions without automatically treating their disapproval as evidence that you’ve done something wrong.
And you can feel increasingly confident that the decisions you’re making reflect your own beliefs, values, and hopes for the future.
Build Relationships Where You Feel Accepted for Who You Are
You can develop friendships and intimate relationships where you feel comfortable being honest about your beliefs, values, and experiences.
You can share personal information without constantly anticipating that someone will gossip about you, withdraw their friendship, or use what you’ve disclosed against you.
Instead of holding back because you’re scared of being rejected again, you can become more comfortable letting people get to know you and allowing relationships to develop.
You’ll also become more confident recognizing when someone isn’t treating you with the respect or consideration you deserve. Rather than repeatedly seeking their approval, you can decide how much access you want that person to have to your life.
You can begin building relationships where closeness develops through mutual trust, affection, and respect, rather than shared religious beliefs or expectations about how you should behave.
Feel Hopeful and Invested in the Life You’re Building
You can come to terms with the loss of the certainty, community, and future you once imagined without feeling that the best parts of your life are behind you.
Perhaps you once believed you knew exactly what adulthood would look like: the marriage you’d have, the children you’d raise, the church you’d attend, and the people who would remain beside you.
Now you’re discovering interests, relationships, and possibilities that weren’t part of that original vision.
You can grieve the life you expected while becoming genuinely excited about the one you’re creating.
Instead of comparing everything to what you’ve lost, you’ll have opportunities to develop meaningful relationships, pursue experiences you care about, and build a sense of belonging that reflects who you are today.
Feel Comfortable Living According to Your Beliefs Without Constantly Fearing Punishment
You can get back to sleeping through the night without lying awake worrying about eternal punishment.
The panic can subside, and reminders of what you were taught can stop leaving you overwhelmed for hours afterward.
You’ll be able to spend your days thinking about things other than whether God is going to punish you for questioning or leaving Christianity.
And when someone expresses disapproval of your decisions, you can recognize that they’re entitled to their beliefs without automatically feeling that you’ve endangered your relationship with God.
You can make choices that reflect what you believe and want now, with less fear that something terrible will happen because you decided for yourself.
Religious Trauma Therapy for Different Faith Backgrounds
I work with adults recovering from harmful religious experiences and spiritual abuse within evangelical, fundamentalist, Catholic, LDS/Mormon, Jehovah’s Witness, and other religious communities.
My experience includes helping people address the effects of strict religious expectations surrounding sexuality, gender roles, obedience, personal decisions, and relationships with religious authorities.
If your experiences involved manipulation, coercive control, or exploitation within a high-control group, you can also learn more about my specialized spiritual abuse and cult recovery therapy.
Online Religious Trauma & Faith Deconstruction Therapy Available Throughout All of California
Areas Served
I’m licensed in California as a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist (LMFT, license #164759), and I provide religious trauma and faith deconstruction therapy through secure, HIPAA-compliant telehealth throughout the state.
This includes:
Los Angeles County, including Los Angeles, Santa Monica, Beverly Hills, West Hollywood, Culver City, Pasadena, Glendale, Burbank, Studio City, Sherman Oaks, Encino, Woodland Hills, Calabasas, Malibu, Manhattan Beach, Redondo Beach, Torrance, Long Beach, and surrounding communities.
Orange County, including Irvine, Newport Beach, Costa Mesa, Huntington Beach, Laguna Beach, Laguna Niguel, Dana Point, San Clemente, Mission Viejo, Lake Forest, Tustin, Orange, Anaheim, Fullerton, and Yorba Linda.
San Diego County, including San Diego, La Jolla, Del Mar, Encinitas, Carlsbad, Oceanside, Solana Beach, Coronado, Chula Vista, Escondido, and San Marcos.
The Inland Empire, including Riverside, Corona, Temecula, Murrieta, Moreno Valley, Redlands, Rancho Cucamonga, Ontario, Upland, and San Bernardino.
The San Francisco Bay Area, including San Francisco, Oakland, Berkeley, Alameda, Emeryville, Walnut Creek, Concord, Lafayette, Orinda, Danville, San Ramon, Pleasanton, Dublin, Fremont, Hayward, San Leandro, San Mateo, Burlingame, Redwood City, Palo Alto, Menlo Park, Mountain View, Sunnyvale, Santa Clara, Cupertino, San Jose, Campbell, Los Gatos, and Saratoga.
The North Bay and Marin County, including San Rafael, Mill Valley, Sausalito, Novato, San Anselmo, Corte Madera, Tiburon, Petaluma, Santa Rosa, Sonoma, Napa, and Vallejo.
The Central Coast, including Santa Barbara, Goleta, Montecito, Carpinteria, Ventura, Oxnard, Thousand Oaks, San Luis Obispo, Paso Robles, Pismo Beach, Arroyo Grande, Santa Maria, Monterey, Carmel, Pacific Grove, Salinas, Santa Cruz, Capitola, and Watsonville.
Sacramento and the surrounding region, including Sacramento, West Sacramento, Davis, Elk Grove, Folsom, Roseville, Rocklin, Lincoln, Auburn, Placerville, and El Dorado Hills.
The Central Valley, including Fresno, Clovis, Madera, Merced, Modesto, Turlock, Stockton, Lodi, Tracy, Visalia, Tulare, Bakersfield, and Hanford.
Northern California, including Redding, Chico, Paradise, Red Bluff, Eureka, Arcata, Fortuna, Ukiah, and surrounding communities.
I work with clients throughout California, including smaller towns and rural areas. You can attend online therapy from anywhere in the state, provided you’re physically located in California at the time of your appointment.
About Ingrid Johnston, LMFT, MDFT
California religious trauma therapist
I’ve been working with individuals and couples since 2014, with training in trauma treatment, somatic therapy, sexual health, and relationship therapy.
My professional experience is informed by my own experiences with faith deconstruction and chronic pain recovery.
I understand how deeply religious teachings can influence your relationships, identity, and expectations for your life, including the emotional effects that remain after your beliefs change.
I combine that cultural understanding with clinical training to help you address the psychological consequences of harmful religious experiences and develop greater confidence in your own decisions.
Logistics & Details
Pricing, Locations, and How to Schedule
Location
I provide individual religious trauma therapy through secure, HIPAA-compliant video sessions for adults physically located in California.
Pricing
Individual sessions are $300 for 55 minutes.
I don’t accept insurance or bill insurance companies directly, but I can provide a Superbill if you’d like to seek out-of-network reimbursement. For more details, please see my pricing page.
How to Get Started in Religious Trauma Therapy
To request your first appointment, choose an available day and time on my secure online calendar using the button directly below.
I’ll review your appointment request and confirm within one business day. Once your appointment is confirmed, you’ll receive new client forms by email to review and digitally sign before we meet.
Questions?
Common Questions About Religious Trauma Therapy in California
Don’t see your question here? Check out my FAQ page.
-
Yes. I have experience working with religious OCD, also called scrupulosity, and I can help you address the fears and compulsive behaviors that are interfering with your life.
Scrupulosity can involve intense fear of sinning, offending God, or making a decision that puts your salvation at risk. You might repeatedly pray, seek reassurance, review your thoughts for evidence that you’ve sinned, or spend hours trying to determine whether you’ve done something morally wrong.
These experiences can overlap with religious trauma, but they aren’t necessarily the same thing. We’ll work together to understand what’s contributing to your difficulties and address the symptoms you’re experiencing, including when OCD and harmful religious experiences are both involved.
-
Yes. I work with clients who remain Christian, are reconsidering particular religious teachings, or have decided to leave their faith.
You can value your relationship with God while recognizing that certain teachings or experiences have caused psychological harm.
In therapy, we can address the fear, guilt, shame, or relationship difficulties associated with those experiences while you decide what role religion and spirituality will have in your life.
My role is to help you trust yourself to know what’s right for you, rather than determine what you should believe.
-
Yes. I provide secure online religious trauma therapy throughout California, including Los Angeles, Orange County, San Diego, the San Francisco Bay Area, Sacramento, and smaller communities.
You don’t need to live near a particular city or office to work with me.
You simply need to be physically located in California at the time of your online appointment.
Have a Question Before Booking?
If you have a question about working together, please contact me using the button below. I’ll respond via email within 2 business days.