Emotionally focused (EFT) couples therapy for marriages where one partner is deconstructing or has left the faith

Couples Therapy for Faith Deconstruction & Faith Transitions

dried flower in EFT couples therapist's office

Faith used to connect you and now it divides you.

One of you no longer believes, or your beliefs have changed. Maybe you’ve stopped going to church, started questioning everything you were taught, or realized you can’t keep living by rules that don’t make sense to you anymore. 

But your partner is still there, still believing, watching you become someone they don’t recognize.

And now your conversations about it end badly.

You try to explain what you’re going through, but your partner shuts down or gets defensive. They try to tell you how upset they are, and you feel attacked or pressured to go back.

Or you’ve both just stopped talking about it entirely because you know exactly how it will go: someone will cry, someone will say something they regret, and you’ll both end up further apart than you were before.

You built this marriage, at least in part, on shared faith. One huge reason you chose each other was because you believed the same things about God, morality, how to live, and how to raise your children.

That foundation is gone now, and neither of you knows if there’s enough left to hold you together.

One of you goes to church alone now


You can’t agree on how to raise the kids spiritually


One of you hides what you think to keep the peace; the other feels like the person you married is disappearing


Church friends have started pulling you aside to ask if everything is okay in your marriage

As a mixed-faith couple, you’re both feeling…

01. Betrayal

The believing partner feels like their spouse broke a fundamental promise. The deconstructing partner often feels betrayed by the religious institution itself, or by a community that rejected them for asking questions. Both people feel betrayed, just in different ways.

02. Shame

The believing partner may feel embarrassed or ashamed that their spouse left, and worried about what people think of them. The deconstructing partner feels guilt about causing their spouse pain, shame about disappointing them, burden about being the reason the marriage is struggling.

03. Lonely

You used to share everything. Now the most important thing happening in each of your lives is something you can’t talk about. The believing partner feels spiritually lonely even when surrounded by their church community because their spouse isn't there. The deconstructing partner lost their entire spiritual community and support system.

04. Grief

Both of you are grieving, and this grief is intense and lasts a long time. The believing partner is grieving the marriage they thought they'd have, the shared spiritual life, the partner who believed the same things. The deconstructing partner is grieving their former self, their certainty, their community, sometimes the person they were for decades.

05. fear

You’re both terrified the marriage will end, terrified you’ll never be understood, terrified of what this means for your kids, what extended family will say, whether you can actually make this work.

dried flowers in EFT couples' therapist office

Being different feels threatening to the relationship.

When you built this relationship, being the same was how you stayed connected. You went to the same church, believed the same things, had the same community, raised your kids with the same values. Your relationship was built on sameness.

You never developed the skills to be two different people with different beliefs and still be close. You don't know how to hold your own position without it feeling like you're rejecting your partner. You don't know how to hear your partner's experience without feeling personally threatened. So every conversation about your differences feels like someone is attacking the relationship.

The believing partner hears their spouse's doubts and questions as: "Everything we built together doesn't matter, I'm leaving you." The deconstructing partner hears their spouse's fear and hurt as: "You need to change back or I can't stay married to you."

Neither of those things is what you're trying to say, but that's what you both hear. So you either fight or you avoid the topic entirely.

Practical decisions are now set up to be potential fights.

It used to be obvious what you'd do on Sunday morning, which holidays you'd celebrate and how, what values you'd teach your kids, how you'd spend money on religious commitments, how you'd relate to extended family who are still in the church.

Now every single one of those decisions is a negotiation or a fight. Do the kids go to church? Do you attend family baptisms? Do you tithe or redirect that money elsewhere? Does the family budget still include religious school tuition or mission trip donations? Do you say grace before meals? Do you go to your partner's church events? Simple questions that used to have automatic answers now require exhausting conversations that often end with someone feeling hurt or resentful.

Sexuality gets complicated for many couples.

If you grew up in purity culture or conservative religious teaching about sex, one or both of you may be dealing with shame about your bodies, confusion about what you want sexually, rigid ideas about gender roles in intimacy.

For some couples, one partner is ready to explore outside the old rules, ready to figure out what they want sexually apart from what they were told they should want. The other partner may still hold those values, or feel threatened by the changes, or not understand why this matters.

You're trying to have a sexual relationship while one or both of you is deprogramming years of teaching that sex is shameful, that certain desires are wrong, that your body is a problem. And you're doing this while already feeling disconnected about everything else. For many couples, sex becomes another area where you feel like strangers to each other.

dried flowers in EFT couples therapist's office

Why books and podcasts haven’t helped…

If you’re like most people in this situation, you’ve likely read books on interfaith marriage or mixed-faith relationships. Maybe you tried to just not talk about it and hope things would settle down. Maybe you sent each other podcasts or articles, trying to help the other person understand your perspective. Maybe you even went to your pastor or religious leader, which likely made one or both of you feel judged or dismissed.

The hard part is that knowing this intellectually doesn’t get you very far. You can understand that you and your partner are allowed to believe different things, but when they say something about their changing faith and your chest tightens, that understanding doesn’t help you respond in the best way. When they express fear about your deconstruction and you feel yourself getting defensive, knowing you’re “supposed to” give each other space doesn’t stop your body from reacting.

You need someone in the room with you who can slow down those moments when you're about to shut down or escalate, who can help you identify what's happening in your body and what you’re really afraid of, who can help both of you stay in the conversation long enough to get underneath the positions to the fears and needs driving them.

How EFT couples therapy addresses faith and identity changes

flowers in EFT couples therapist's office

I work with couples using Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT) as the foundation, integrated with somatic and trauma-informed approaches. The work focuses on learning how to be deeply connected while holding different beliefs.

You stop interpreting your partner’s different beliefs as rejection

Right now, being different feels like the end of your marriage. When your partner says "I don't believe anymore" or "I need to stay in the church," you interpret this as disconnection, or even the end of the marriage.

We work with what's actually happening underneath: the terror of losing each other, the fear that you can't both be yourselves and stay together.

In session, we slow down the moments when you start to feel threatened. We work with the fear that difference means rejection, the panic that you're losing each other. When one of you says "I'm not going to church anymore" and the other says "I'm sad and scared about that," we work with both of those realities. Neither person has to fix the other's feelings or change their position.

This means you can mention reading a deconstruction book without your partner panicking, you can express sadness about going to church alone without your partner feeling attacked, you can disagree about raising your kids in the faith without someone always having to give in. You discover you can have different beliefs in the same house, in the same marriage, without it feeling like a countdown to divorce.

You learn to grieve together instead of in isolation

The believing partner is grieving the theologically unified marriage they thought they'd have, grieving sitting together at church, grieving the certainty about raising kids with shared values. The deconstructing partner is grieving their former self, their community, their sense of certainty about the world.

Right now you're both drowning in your own grief and can't hold space for the other's. We work with both losses at the same time, helping you support each other through this instead of treating each other like the enemy. This means when your partner is hurting about the faith changes, you can be there for them even though you're the one who changed, and when you're grieving what you've lost, your partner can support you even though they're scared about what it means.

flowers in mixed-faith marriage couples therapist's office

You rebuild sexual connection when shame or conflicting beliefs are in the way

If purity culture teachings are creating problems in your sexual relationship, we work on that directly. This means identifying what you were taught versus what you want, processing shame about bodies and desire through somatic work, rebuilding sexual connection when the old framework no longer works for one or both of you.

For couples where one person has deconstructed those teachings and the other hasn't, we work on reconnecting emotionally and physically in ways that honor both people. This means you can explore what feels good without your partner feeling threatened or rejected, you can express that certain things don't work for you anymore without your partner taking it as personal rejection, you can have a sex life that works for both of you even when you're coming from different belief systems.

You face the hard decisions and outside pressure as a team

As you develop the ability to stay emotionally connected even when you disagree, the overwhelming questions about kids, church, money, and extended family become decisions you can navigate together instead of battles you fight against each other.

This means you can talk about whether the kids go to church without someone's beliefs automatically winning, you can handle your mother-in-law's pressure to "fix" your spouse without turning on each other, you can decide what to do about tithing or religious school costs without resentment building on either side. The decisions don't have easy answers, but you're working on them as partners instead of adversaries.

You find what still connects you underneath the beliefs that changed

When the religious beliefs that used to bind you together are gone or different, it can feel like you have nothing in common anymore. We help you find the values, the vision for your life, the things that matter to you that you still share, even if you express or practice them differently now.

This means you discover shared commitments to honesty, kindness, raising good humans even when you disagree about the religious framework for doing that, you create new rituals that work for both of you instead of only doing things that fit one person's beliefs, and you build connection on who you actually are now instead of who you used to be.

This works best when both partners…

  • Are committed to staying in the relationship even though you’re scared about whether it will work

  • Are willing to learn how to be different instead of needing the other person to change back

  • Can tolerate the discomfort of not having this figured out yet

This approach won’t work well if…

  • One partner is using faith changes as a cover for wanting to leave the relationship

  • There’s active abuse or control happening: spiritual, emotional, or otherwise

  • One person is completely unwilling to respect the other’s right to hold different beliefs

Online Couples Therapy in Washington for Mixed-Faith or Deconstructing Couples

When one of you stopped believing and the other didn’t, the marriage you built together started operating on two different foundations. I work with couples in exactly that place, throughout Washington State, including in Seattle, Bellevue, Tacoma, Vancouver, and Spokane.

I see clients via telehealth on Tuesdays and Wednesdays between 8am-6pm. I also offer in-person sessions on Mondays at my Bothell office through summer 2026.

Ingrid Johnston, LMFT

About Ingrid Johnston, LMFT, MDFT
Couples therapist for mixed-faith or deconstructing couples

I’ve been working with individuals and couples since 2014, with specialized training in trauma, somatic therapy, and faith transitions. I hold a Master of Science in Marriage and Family Therapy and advanced certification in Medical Family Therapy and Collaborative Medicine from Seattle Pacific University.

My approach integrates EMDR, somatic therapy, and Emotion-Focused Therapy (EFT), evidence-based modalities specifically effective for religious trauma and complex PTSD. I’ve completed over 100 hours of specialized training in trauma treatment and body-based healing.

Beyond my clinical training, my work is informed by my own lived experience. I grew up immersed in traditional Christian faith. I’ve navigated my own path through chronic pain, somatic healing, and decades of mindfulness and meditation practices. I understand what it's like to rebuild trust in your body and intuition after being taught they couldn’t be trusted.

I’m a member of the American Association for Marriage and Family Therapy (AAMFT) and the Washington Association for Marriage and Family Therapy (WAMFT).

Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist: Washington State License #LF61033631

Questions?

FAQs About EFT Couples Therapy for Mixed-Faith & Deconstructing Couples

Don’t see your question answered here? Check my FAQ page.

  • Couples sessions are $350 for 50 minutes.

  • I don't accept insurance directly, which keeps your therapy records private and our work focused on what you actually need rather than what an insurance company will approve.

    A note specific to couples therapy: most insurance plans won't reimburse for couples sessions, even out of network. Couples therapy uses a relational diagnosis code, which means the diagnosis applies to what's happening between you as a couple, rather than to either of you individually, and most plans don't cover that. All couples session fees are paid directly out of pocket. If you have an HSA or FSA account, those funds can typically be used, but check with your plan administrator to confirm.

  • No — I don’t share my personal beliefs in session, and I don’t have an opinion about where either of you should land with your faith. What I care about is whether you can be honest with each other without it threatening the relationship.

  • Some people find religion and spirituality deeply helpful and beneficial. If that’s your experience, I’m not here to change your beliefs. My focus is helping you and your partner navigate the fact that you’re in different places, not moving either of you toward a particular destination.

    This work is about learning to be different from each other without that difference meaning the relationship is over.

  • Yes. But it requires something most couples weren’t taught to do: stay emotionally connected to someone who sees the world differently than you do. That’s a learnable skill, and it’s the core of what we work on together.

    The marriages that struggle most aren’t the ones where beliefs changed. They’re the ones where both people are so afraid of the difference that they stop being honest, stop being curious about each other, and start protecting themselves instead of reaching for each other.

  • Pastoral counseling and therapy are doing different things. A pastor is usually working within a framework of shared belief and often has a perspective on what the “right” outcome looks like. I don’t.

    I'm also trained to work with what's happening in your nervous system during these conversations, not just the content of what you're saying. When your partner brings up their changing beliefs and your chest tightens or your mind goes blank, that's a trauma response, and knowing you "should" stay calm doesn't help your body cooperate. That's the piece most counseling approaches miss.

  • Most couples therapists are trained to work with communication, conflict patterns, and compromise. Those are useful, but when the issue involves faith, identity, trauma, and deeply held beliefs about morality and meaning, communication tools alone tend to fall short.

    My approach works with the emotional and physical responses driving your conflicts, not just the topics you're fighting about. We slow things down enough to understand what each of you is actually feeling underneath the defensiveness or withdrawal, and we work with that directly. For a lot of couples, that's the piece that was missing.

  • I ask couples to commit to three months of weekly sessions to start. That gives us enough time and consistency to move past the surface issues and into the patterns underneath. After that, if we're seeing real progress, we can talk about shifting to every other week.

    Therapy for faith transitions tends to take longer than therapy for a single presenting problem, because the issues touch so many areas of your life — parenting, sex, community, family relationships, identity. Most couples I work with in this space are in therapy for several months to a year.

  • We're usually working with whatever is happening between you right now. If you had a hard conversation during the week, we'll start there. I'll slow things down, help each of you identify what you were actually feeling underneath the anger or shutdown, and guide you through a different way of sharing that with each other.

    I pay close attention to your body during session — where you hold tension, when your breathing changes, when one of you checks out. A lot of the work happens in those moments, because that's where the old patterns live. I'm more directive than some therapists you may have worked with, which means I'll coach you through how to stay present and how to receive what your partner is sharing, rather than just reflecting what I hear.

  • No. Faith is usually the catalyst, but the work is about your relationship. We'll talk about how you handle difference, how you reach for each other (or don't) when you're scared, how you make decisions together when you don't share the same framework anymore. Sometimes that involves religion directly, and sometimes it shows up in conversations about parenting, sex, holidays, or what you're going to tell your families.

Work through this faith transition with your partner instead of alone.

You don’t have to choose between being yourself and staying in your relationship. You can hold different beliefs and still be deeply connected. This requires learning skills you probably didn’t have when you were building your relationship, but those skills can be learned. I can help.

Get In Touch

Contact Ingrid

Please complete the form, and I will be in touch within 48 business hours.

Office and mailing address:

19803 North Creek Parkway, Suite 205
Bothell, WA 98011

In-person in Bothell & online across Washington